Search This Blog

Showing posts with label value. Show all posts
Showing posts with label value. Show all posts

Monday, 2 September 2013

The Value of Encouraging Direct Debit Payments

A direct debit is an instruction that a bank account holder (usually a merchant) gives their bank to collect a variable amount directly from another account (usually a given customer). A direct debit is also often called a pre-authorised debit or pre-authorised payment. Direct debits are initiated by the recipient (merchant), as opposed to the Payer (customer), which means that the payer is not in control of the payment. This is quite different to a standing order, which tends to be set up by a customer as a fixed amount payment and can be cancelled by them at any time.

Direct debit payments have become very popular with large merchants in recent years (such as utilities, telecom companies and councils for example) because they allow the merchant to obtain an open mandate from a customer to transfer variable amounts of money out of a bank account on a regular basis.  This make direct debit apparently very good for the merchant (with high levels of control over customer payments). But is this really the case as in reality there are both pros and cons to consider?
 
ADVANTAGES:
DISADVANTAGES:
1. Having a direct debit mandate saves a merchant time as automatic payment is set up to occur regularly by a customer on a given date. The payment is also known and easily reconciled as thee are full records of the transaction.
 
2. Direct debits tend to avoid late payments by a customer (avoiding chase letters or phone calls or even worse, disconnection notices, and late fees and penalties.
 
3. Direct debit is cost effective for the merchant as a payment method (at least on the surface-see point 4 in disadvantages). A merchant typically gains the benefit of planned cash-flow at a very low cost (with direct debits costing between a fixed15-25 pence on average).
 
4. Direct debits provide more security for the merchant and the customer by being made electronically. This is both secure and proof of payment appears on the customer bank statement.
 
1. A customer needs to trust a given merchant to give bank account access to them or to want to sign a mandate.
 
2. A customer account has to have adequate funds to cover payments when they’re due. If this is not the case, apart from the loss of payment (and cash-flow) a reversal will occur (see point 4)
 
3. A bank account may be closed by the bank due to fraud or some other reason.  This will lead to reversal fees (see point 4 below.)
 
4. Reversals across UK direct debits run at about 4 in one hundred (4%) and cause considerable problems for the merchant. It may cost as much as £30 to set up a new direct debit with a customer. What this means in practice is that these 4 in 100 reversals have to be spread over all 100 (or £120 in total divided by 100 or £1.20 needs to be added to the 20 pence average cost). This means that the real cost of a direct debit is more like £1.40 on average.
 
5. If a Payer wants to change banks, a merchant will need to set up new direct debit mandates again which is time consuming. Also, merchants need to keep a record of any direct debit mandate from their customers for a 7 year period.
 

 There is an alternative to direct debit that is available at www.payswyft.com. This is called “dynamic debit” and is set up by the customer rather than the merchant. This payment method is most typically linked with a customer’s debit card (although a credit card can also be used). These recurrent payments can be made indefinitely on a variable basis like a direct debit, but has one major difference. A customer can set a maximum limit (say £50) and have the Payswyft system alert them (by SMS or email) so that they can approve the payment (or query it with the merchant before it is settled). As the cost of this debit-side payment is around 35 pence each time (and has almost no risk of cancellation, reversal or chargeback as transactions are run through the 3D secure system) they are a true win-win for both the merchant and the customer.

Sunday, 25 November 2012

What is the real cost of paper-based versus electronic billing

This might seem to be quite a simple question at face value but when we think about it, the answer is not exactly a straightforward one. This is because we are not always aware of the real costs of performing this quite complex task in all of its steps. In addition, while direct or tangible costs are relatively easy to identify, indirect costs are less easily identifiable and some of these are often very well hidden. Let’s therefore look at what tends to fall into these three categories of costs when comparing traditional paper-based billing versus full on-line or digital billing.

Direct Costs
At face value most people would estimate that a few “direct” costs are involved in paper-based billing. These may include:
•Invoice bill/file preparation/printing
•Paper invoices/bills
•Printing (ink or cartridge replacement)
•Envelopes
•Postage/Franking
•Offering basic payment options (debit, credit, other at standard fees)
Costs will fall as bill volumes increase for most of the above but even if they do postage or franking at about £0.40 to £0.45 pence will always be the biggest fee here. And the others will typically add as much as 30 to 35 pence making for a total of £0.70 to £0.80 of direct costs. Of course, if a merchant emails invoices (with a PDF attachment), instead of physically mailing them this may fall in half perhaps.

Indirect Costs
Costs are often deemed to be “indirect” because they are either fixed and/or cannot be wholly charged to the billing costs (especially if it is only part of a person’s job). However, even proportional costs add up here. Indirect costs may include:
•Customer service manpower to handle calls/queries
•Accounting/Reconciliation manpower
•Lost invoices (and the time taken to deal with this)
•Undelivered bills (and the time taken to deal with this)
•The cost of bill storage (space rental or fixed costs)
•Bill query handling time
Once again there may be some economies of scale in the above but all of these items (except bill storage perhaps) mainly involve having staff on the payroll or at call. Even at 500 bills a month, at least quarter a person would typically be involved in issuing and reconciling invoices and another quarter in handling queries, re-issuing bills or handling “special requests” related to invoicing or payments. If the cost of this person (or two part-timers) were £12,000 a year (£8,000 plus 50% salary/overhead burden) or £6,000 each, this £1,000 a month would amount to £2 per bill.

Hidden Costs
Costs are often deemed to be “hidden” because no-one is scrutinising or controlling them (they go unmeasured or unaccounted for or are lost in general overhead or the broad costs of doing business). Hidden costs may include:
•Extra or hidden payment transaction fees (which may be fixed or higher than necessary)
•Invoice/billing run or payment processing errors
•The need for a higher than wanted or necessary float/overdraft at the bank
•Possible added customers or more business from having more payment options
•Quicker settlement/cycle time (by use of SMS or email alerts)
•Easier training of staff/opportunity to focus staff elsewhere with time saved
•Potential cash-flow acceleration
•Easier/cheaper compliance and audit work with digital billing
•Lower/No cost digital marketing opportunities
•Overall incremental "Green" benefits/credits

The benefits to an organisation of the long list above are obviously much harder to calculate but a variety of studies in recent years have suggested that these can conservatively add up to as much as 3-4% of revenues or as much as 15% of profit. If we assume our little company doing 500 bills a month has an average transaction or “ticket” value of £40, turnover per month is £20,000 or £240,000 per annum. If we assume that profit is 15% of this or £36,000, this all means that the cost per bill is somewhere between £0.90 to £1.20.

So in summary, if we add all of these costs together which have a total traditional or paper-based billing cost of £3.60 to £4 or 9.5% of the revenue collected each time (£40 average ticket value). Now that’s a quite a serious amount of money for this little company not to take pretty seriously! But what about your company?-what is 9.5% of your revenues? And when you have calculated it in cold hard cash, can you afford not to investigate the potential to save as much as half of this as recurrent savings every year by moving to digital billing?