Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Digital billing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Digital billing. Show all posts

Monday, 3 February 2014

Are emailed invoices just as good as digital ones?

Most people now believe that electronic invoicing offers significant advantages over paper-based processes (saving direct costs like printing an invoice, stamping an envelope and sending it in the mail etc. and saving indirect costs such as lost invoices, late and missing checks in the mail and often much more difficult reconciliation). However, there is not always agreement on what the term “electronic invoicing” actually means and in this brief article we will look at two very different kinds of e-invoicing-emailed invoices and digital invoices. These are often perceived to be similar and/or equivalent methods but, as we will see, they are actually quite different.

Emailed invoices

Sending an invoice via email is usually done these days by attaching the invoice as an Adobe PDF document. This allows the invoice to be sent cheaply and quickly to the recipient who can use a free product (Adobe Acrobat Reader) to open and view it. The simple idea here is that once the customer has reviewed the document (and even saved it to his or her hard drive) he or she can then pay it. In theory (especially in Business to Consumer or B2C markets) the invoice is not only sent out quickly (and at much lower costs than traditional invoicing methods) but means that the customer can send back a check or phone in a credit card payment within hours or just a few days (and well ahead of the latest date he or should could technically pay) thereby helping to accelerate merchant cash-flow. Unfortunately, although this works in some situations, the process is rarely this smooth and a number of problems can occur.

Firstly, the merchant needs to have a customer’s email address to be able to send a PDF. Secondly, the PDF is still a flat document which most customers will not only have to open, but will often print and put in a pile to deal with later, when they are ready (just like receiving the paper-based invoice in the mail). This means that the customer may wait as long as they did before to pay the invoice (assuming they do not lose their printed piece of paper in the meantime having deleted their original email). In addition to all of this, an emailed PDF does not encourage the customer to pay by electronic means any more than an invoice arriving in the mail does. Research suggests that customers actually often like to have the option to pay online by debit or credit card for example and can often only do so by calling the merchant (and having to spend time and effort, and within the hours of business operated by the call-center). Finally, in Business to Business (or B2B) invoicing, the emailed PDF presents a whole new layer of challenges as these often require a digital signature. PDF technology is now much better at allowing digital signatures to be securely added to invoices when they are sent in the mail. However, the process is by no means simple and presents many logistical issues, particularly when multiple approval signatures are required.

Digital invoices

A digital invoice is available at a web site. Sometimes this is embedded in part of a merchant’s web site or it is “hosted” on a third-party web site (to which customers can go directly or can be redirected from a link on a merchant’s web site). In most cases, the digital invoice rendering process is even quicker than emailed invoices, as there is no need to generate a PDF and attach it to an email address. In addition, although a customer may be notified that a new invoice is available via email, it is not necessary to have an email address (as the customer can be notified about the web address by normal physical mail and then subscribe to the web site service to be later notified by either email or even their mobile phone –via SMS). In practice this means that digital invoices will often collect or “scrape” new email addresses from customers progressively.

Perhaps most importantly, a digital invoice is viewed in a truly online way (and does not require printing (as it can be easily stored and retrieved permanently or resent by a merchant at almost no extra cost). This means that not only can the customer view the invoice (in as much detail as they wish) but they can use many online features to both deal with the invoice (save it, schedule it for later payment or send it on for viewing or approval to another person) or even just pay it immediately of course. And if they do choose to pay it immediately, they typically get to do so via their debit card if they want to use their current bank account or by a variety of credit card options (and in some cases even by cash by printing out a voucher and taking it to a local newsagent or local store that takes cash payments). This is therefore much more likely to accelerate merchant cash-flow than in the emailed invoice situation and means that the payment is much easier to reconcile (as less difficult to reconcile checks or phone-based payments are being made). Finally, the invoice recipient (whether it is a B2C one or B2B one) can elect to pay a bill 24/7 as the bill presentment and payment web site is truly “open-all-hours”.

Conclusion

Emailed invoices are superior to traditional invoices sent in the mail. However, they fall far short of full digital invoices, which offer many additional benefits (which translate into much greater time and cost saving for the merchant). These two approaches are therefore far from equivalent and a merchant can realize considerable advantages by upgrading from an emailed invoice to a full digital one.

Saturday, 24 August 2013

Can Merchants really turn off paper bills with digital billing?

Within the billing world, going paperless has been almost like a “Holy Grail” for many merchants, and especially those who are sending out thousands, hundreds of thousands or even millions of bills a month in some cases. And who can blame them? Merchants who send out more than just a few hundred invoices each month are typically spending a great deal of money on printing, putting invoices into envelopes, sending out reminders and/or statements, franking the envelope, having to engage in making sure bills are filed or stored properly and fielding calls from customers who don’t receive a the bill in the mail at all (so it has to be resent) to name but a few things.

By adopting a paperless invoice or digital bill only solution, a merchant can technically avoid all of the above and “switch off paper” immediately. However, despite the apparent significant  advantages to the merchant, this may not be the best way to go (and it should also not be the driver of the change to digital billing).

Most customers have been getting bills in the mail, or at least ones they can print if they are sent by email, for many years and many want to stick with a process that they well understand. Hence, any merchant that removes the option of receiving a paper bill risks losing a customer’s business altogether. Far better therefore to retain the option to receive a physical bill and either deliver it by cost-effective e-mail or allow a customer to retrieve it and print it for themselves from a central website.

With a cloud-based system such as PaySwyft, not only can any merchant post a digital bill but allow customers to print the bill whenever they like. Even better a merchant can email the bill if they so wish, including follow-up or chase bills. And once customers are using such a fully digital portal they can also use a whole range of convenient technology to manage their bill in more flexible ways. This includes:
Receiving a monthly e-mail notification when a new invoice is available to view.
  • Decreasing the possibility of mail fraud and identity theft.
  • Automatically calendarising or secheduling payments at a time or date to suit them
  • Set email and/or SMS alerts as they like
  • Store and retrieve all invoice and payment records whenever they like, forever
  • Make payment 24 hours a day, 365 days a year
  • Pay in a multitude of ways at the same portal and get a receipt there and then
  • See all of their invoices and payments when they want
  • Analyse invoice trends and patterns as they wish
This does not mean that they will necessarily “turn off” the paper bill, or stop printing it, but over time the resistance to doing so will clearly lessen. And in the meantime, not only is the customer getting a convenient service for free, that they can use at work or home on their computer (and save themselves time if they were previously paying by cash or cheque in particular), but a merchant is saving money on many fronts, including fielding less phone calls, accelerating cash-flow with earlier online payments and reconciling payments in a much more straightforward way than ever before. Given all of this, getting to a paperless world, if and when it happens, is only a minor bonus.


Sunday, 21 July 2013

Finding and Using the Right Invoice Template

If you type “free invoice template” into the Google search engine you get about 40 million returned results. Clearly then there is a lot of interest in trying to find and use an effective invoice process (and ideally a cheap or free one) so in this article we will explore what is available and what options appear to deliver the greatest benefits.

Whether you are a one person business or a giant multi-national, getting an invoice to a customer is the beginning a long process in getting paid. Hence, it is important to get this invoice to a customer quickly (once a product has been supplied or service rendered) but it is equally critical that it is clear and encourages the earliest possible payment.

Fifty years ago, hand-written or simply typed invoices sent through the mail were the norm. Today, we have many other options (although these old-fashioned practices have far from disappeared completely). Perhaps the simplest of these is to use an pre-designed template and popular desk top applications like word for windows and an excel spreadsheet package both have several design alternatives to choose from. In both cases these provide a well-designed looking invoices and provide prompt space for particular customer names, address details, product or services provided and the cost involved. They even allow space for logos to be added if desired. 

Outside the standard templates of desktop applications, there are many relatively cheap and even free software packages which allow invoices to be generated. These work in similar ways to desktop templates but may also generate sequential numbers and allow better storage and retrieval (and avoid the mistake prone process of overtyping the last invoice that was typed).

In both of the above alternatives, the problem is that despite the fact that the invoice can be sent by email as an attachment is still only received as a piece of paper (which the customer can do little with when they receive it and may only print in order to later pay in any case).  As a result, perhaps the best alternative of all is to use a bill presentment service which renders the invoice as a full digital bill. This allows individuals to click on an electronic bill at a web site (ideally rendered in graphical form as they would expect to see it as it appears when posted) and either reveal more bill detail, store it, end it on to someone else to review and most importantly to pay it.

For example, at the PaySwyft web site (www.payswyft.com) sole traders, partnership and companies or all sizes can click on the “free invoice template link” on the home page and use the system to generate an invoice at no cost whatsoever. Like the options described above it provides an clear and clean process for entering invoice details but this is rendered as a full digital bill, meaning that it can be clicked on dynamically to see as much detail as has been entered and perhaps more importantly, it can be paid from within the browser, also electronically. The added bonus here is that the single invoice can then be used (when saved) as a template to generate future invoices much more quickly (because a logo has been added and the design of the overall invoice is relatively set).

Wednesday, 19 June 2013

Are PDF Invoices better or worse than old-fashioned paper invoices?

A recent study published by AIIM on progress towards the paperless office makes interesting reading as it relates to current billing practices. The study is worth taking note of because apart from AIIM being a credible non-profit research business which has been around for almost 70 years, as the chart below indicates it was a very large survey of companies of almost all sizes. In addition, the study went to companies in multiple sectors all over the world (although around 50% of the companies were in the US).

 



What the Study Showed
As we all know, the capability to exchange PDF files as e-mail attachments is said to have reduced the volume of paperwork traded between companies and small businesses considerably. However, this study says that the reduction is minimal at best, but quite possibly creates more paperwork than it saves.

In specific terms, the study revealed the following facts about PDF as invoices
  • Over three-quarters of people surveyed say one of the first things they do with a PDF-based invoice… is print it out.
  • From the 77% of the 395 respondents that print out their invoices, 16% scan the invoices right back into the system for use as……PDF attachments.
  • 10% of people print out their PDF invoices multiple times.
  • 10% of people say they print out at least one copy for archival purposes.
The chart relating to this data is shown below: 
 

What is happening to Invoices?
Although many of the larger companies in the survey seem to be pressing to have all-electronic billing and payment systems, it seems that we are still a long way from this ideal (perhaps as few as 2-3% of companies have a fully digital system which includes no printing and only digital storage systems). However, many businesses are at least trying to save on postage and paper costs by sending invoices as PDF files, or as faxes. However, even here the invoices are often printed out as paper, sometimes at both ends, which almost completes defeats the object. Such practices obviously do not generally result in a reduction of paper within the receiving business in particular. As we saw from the statistics earlier in total, 77% of respondents are likely to print at least one copy of a PDF invoice, and 16% admit to printing it out and then scanning it in for capture, as do 31% receiving a faxed invoice.

Are new more “intelligent” PDF’s the answer?
Most respondents to the AIIM survey were referring to the basic PDF files generated by their Acrobat software, which are obviously less feature-rich than intelligent PDFs have become in recent years with functionality such as XML files being included with all the relevant invoices and embedded payment buttons and even digital signature capture systems. Although this is undoubtedly an improvement, the adoption of these more function-rich PDFs has been very slow and in most cases has had little impact on the rate at which companies of all sizes continue to print out and scan invoices. This is partly because, a PDF is still regarded as paper in real terms-it may be electronic but it is not easy to digitize in ways that are useful for data transfer and exchange. Full digitalization is therefore the goal of many organizations and this is why scanning remains popular. In this regard, when asked what the biggest drivers are for scanning, responses were mainly about data-exchange, availability and flexibility (as the chart below from the survey indicates).

 
So what are the implications?
PDF’s are very convenient as a way to send documents electronically but far less so when it is an invoice. The speed of the sending process is better than physical mailing but so many people are printing it out anyway, it is far short of being the “path to digitization” that companies of all sizes want or need. Fully digital invoices seem to be a much more attractive option and when an invoice can be presented in full in third-party cloud-based portals such as those such at PaySwyft, any company gets all of this immediately.

Monday, 3 June 2013

Can Better Billing Practices Improve Merchant Cash-flow, Cost Effectiveness and Customer Satisfaction?

Or why does efficient and effective billing practices deliver greater Cash-flow, Cost effectiveness and Customer Satisfaction for the merchant and more Convenience, Clarity/Certainty and Choice for the consumer-the 6 C’s

Billing is never the most exciting of subjects for business owners or managers, coming as it does as the last and perhaps most administrative or clerical step in the sales to delivery cycle. However, being a last step should not relegate it to being the least important and there is actually plenty of evidence to suggest that efficient billing practices may be one of the most critical. In this article we will therefore briefly explore why better billing practices can have a significant impact on cash-flow, cost-effectiveness and customer satisfaction for the merchant (as well as several equally beneficial, and linked outcomes for their customers).

Before we look at each of these 3 merchant benefits in turn, let’s define what we mean by “efficient billing practices”. Presenting a bill or invoice can clearly be done in person (albeit rarely), in the physical mail (with a stamp), via an email (typically with a PDF attachment) or by digital means (via an Internet web site). All four of these options can be relatively “efficient” if they reach the right person quickly and facilitate the earliest possible settlement. However, experience (and much research) tells us that these practices are likely to be progressively more effective in the order in which they are listed. In other words, a full digital presentment of the bill is likely to be a much better option that delivering a bill by email, which in turn is better than doing so by physical mail etc. In this article we will therefore assume that a merchant will have, or aspire to have, the most efficient and effective approach –a full digital e-bill and it will be our contention that getting this bill delivered allows all the benefits we will elaborate upon subsequently to follow. The diagram below illustrates this rather more visually.
 

© PaySwyft, 2011. All Rights Reserved
Greater Cash-flow
The vast majority of organisations that supply a product or render a service to another organisation, or an end consumer, usually do so on credit terms (a lucky few get paid ahead of time of course). To operate somewhat like a lending bank, an organisation must therefore use shareholder funds, cash in its bank account,  supplier credit (if they have any) or other money that is borrowed in some way (with interest being payable). These credit terms, or what is sometimes easier to visualise as the time taken to receive payment from customers, can have a huge impact on the working capital needed by a business and thereby have a critical affect on cash-flow. From the point of the delivery, spending days preparing and sending an invoice along with offering normal credit terms for a given industry (say 30 day terms on average), might mean that a particular enterprise may have an average days outstanding in practice of 40-45 days to get paid. Even for a relatively small business turning over say £500,000 a year this would mean working capital of £30,000 needs to be maintained just to stay in business (or in this case 6% of turnover).

Given the above, if a merchant takes its billing practices seriously, it should present an invoice to the customer in the fastest way possible (ideally digitally, the day after delivery-or even the same day perhaps). In addition, with a full digital bill, an opportunity can be offered to check that the bill has all the information that the customer needs to see and in as much detail and as they need to see it. This creates clarity and certainty that they are paying appropriately for what they have received. On a digitally presented bill, “clickable” payment options can allow the customer to render payment immediately (at the same web site and in the same session) or perhaps schedule a payment there and then (especially if there are multiple payment choices available, which we will look at later). All of this combines to ensure that invoice days outstanding are reduced, in some cases by up to 30-40%. This clearly has a very positive impact on cash-flow and allows working capital to be reduced or freed up for other uses (in the above small business example it could lead to 2-3% of total revenue in savings).

Greater Cost Effectiveness
It is estimated that physical bills (paper-base ones) still account for around 80% of the total volume of bills in all major economies, where there is good data to measure it such as the UK, Australia, Canada, France, Holland, Germany, New Zealand, Singapore, Sweden, and the US (amongst others).

The direct costs of preparing an invoice and sending it in the mail alone are relatively high, especially in an age when we can send almost any document electronically. However, they are even higher when you factor in the indirect costs associated with the potential for keying errors, mis-delivery and loss and the extra time often needed for accounting and reconciliation (to name but a few problems). The email based bill (now accounting for around 15% of the total volume of bills according to most research) removes some of the direct costs above, but almost none of the indirect costs of keying errors and mis-delivery, and extra time needed for accounting and reconciliation. The full digital bill is the only option therefore which has the scope to make a large dent in both direct and indirect costs.

With a well-designed system, a fully digital billing approach allows the customer to see the full bill immediately it is delivered (24/7 and 365 days a year) to analyse it versus other bills from the same merchant potentially and to immediately effect payment (or plan for it to occur on the system). This therefore affords much greater customer convenience (especially when they can use the system for their own personal bill storage and not have to wait for a merchant call-centre to be open to take a payment, for instance). However, the major benefits to the merchant are in having a full electronic record of each transaction (individually or in aggregate), with as much detail as they wish to see. And by maintaining the whole billing process in electronic form, all the data can flow in digital form in all directions, including reconciliation in the accounting system-thereby saving many labour hours and costs.

Greater Customer Satisfaction
When customers are asked about their overall experiences of organisational billing (in general) they will tend to mention three factors more than any other.

The first is that it should offer “clarity and certainty”. By this they typically mean that it should be a clear and easy to follow invoice, be accurate, be securely delivered to them and reflect what they have purchased in a certain way.

Secondly, they will typically say that a bill should be “conveniently” presented.  Mailing it may meet this need (physically or by email) but digitally allows it to be viewed at any time day and night and, if it is user-friendly enough, can allow for further detail to be scrutinised, when desired.

Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, customers will nominate the need for “choice” to be available to them. On the presentment side this may be whether to pay the bill now or later or to set up a scheduled or recurrent payment (with associated electronic alerts and reminders to an email account of mobile phone, as needed). On the payment side, this may be to have lots of immediate and widespread payment types or options to be used on both the debit and credit side if possible. In a well-designed digital billing web site, all of this can be available with an even greater range of choices being available in terms of individual customer preferences, in many cases.

Summary
In conclusion then it should by now be clear that the apparently basic and administrative item of a simple bill to a customer can be presented in a way that can have a significant bearing on Cash-flow, Cost Control and Customer Satisfaction. A well-designed and fully electronic or digital billing process will typically give the best results and all organisations should therefore consider moving to such a system as quickly as possible, especially if they can add it as an additional channel to existing practices (minimising disruption) and on a pay-as-you-go basis (as offered by systems such as PaySwyft for example).

 

 

 

Monday, 6 May 2013

Can Merchants really turn off paper bills with digital billing?

Within the billing world, going paperless has been almost like a “Holy Grail” for many merchants, and especially those who are sending out thousands, hundreds of thousands or even millions of bills a month in some cases. And who can blame them? Merchants who send out more than just a few hundred invoices each month are typically spending a great deal of money on printing, putting invoices into envelopes, sending out reminders and/or statements, franking the envelope, having to engage in making sure bills are filed or stored properly and fielding calls from customers who don’t receive a the bill in the mail at all (so it has to be resent) to name but a few things.
 
By adopting a paperless invoice or digital bill only solution, a merchant can technically avoid all of the above and “switch off paper” immediately. However, despite the apparent significant advantages to the merchant, this may not be the best way to go (and it should also not be the driver of the change to digital billing).

Most customers have been getting bills in the mail, or at least ones they can print if they are sent by email, for many years and many want to stick with a process that they well understand. Hence, any merchant that removes the option of receiving a paper bill risks losing a customer’s business altogether. Far better therefore to retain the option to receive a physical bill and either deliver it by cost-effective e-mail or allow a customer to retrieve it and print it for themselves from a central website.

With a cloud-based system such as PaySwyft, not only can any merchant post a digital bill but allow customers to print the bill whenever they like. Even better a merchant can email the bill if they so wish, including follow-up or chase bills. And once customers are using such a fully digital portal they can also use a whole range of convenient technology to manage their bill in more flexible ways. This includes:
 
  • Receiving a monthly e-mail notification when a new invoice is available to view.
  • Decreasing the possibility of mail fraud and identity theft.
  • Automatically calendarising or secheduling payments at a time or date to suit them
  • Set email and/or SMS alerts as they like
  • Store and retrieve all invoice and payment records whenever they like, forever
  • Make payment 24 hours a day, 365 days a year
  • Pay in a multitude of ways at the same portal and get a receipt there and then
  • See all of their invoices and payments when they want
  • Analyse invoice trends and patterns as they wish
This does not mean that they will necessarily “turn off” the paper bill, or stop printing it, but over time the resistance to doing so will clearly lessen. And in the meantime, not only is the customer getting a convenient service for free, that they can use at work or home on their computer (and save themselves time if they were previously paying by cash or cheque in particular), but a merchant is saving money on many fronts, including fielding less phone calls, accelerating cash-flow with earlier online payments and reconciling payments in a much more straightforward way than ever before. Given all of this, getting to a paperless world, if and when it happens, is only a minor bonus.

Tuesday, 22 January 2013

Paperless billing-a cost effective and sustainable solution?

“Eco friendly” and “budget friendly” don’t always go hand in hand. But paperless billing is one of those rare measures that checks both boxes – all while keeping customers happy.  This is simply because getting a bill to a consumer in a traditional way takes lots of time, effort and money that can be avoided. However, by using modern internet technology, the bill issue time can be reduced, the effort to get the bill out can be lessened and costs can be squeezed or in some cases eliminated.

Let’s look a look at some of the specific wins:

Any business of any size or type wins on cost.  On the direct or visible cost side, there’s less paper, less envelopes, less ink, less postage. Even though these are often significant in and of themselves there are also big potential cost reductions on the indirect or more hidden side of things...less customer support (handling queries or phone-in payments) and much less time spent on reconciliation. In addition, online bill presentment and payment has been shown to lead to much quicker settlement by the customer-which substantially aids cash-flow for a merchant. All these savings add up.

The customer wins – This includes eliminating or simplifying the tasks of organising bills, querying them and being able to make payments (all being possible safely and securely at a single web site typically with a few clicks). Paper free means more free time for the bill payer, and less to worry about when dealing with paper (including having to put the bill or invoice somewhere safe, finding it when needed and even losing it occasionally).

The environment wins.  Paperless billing is a simple but significant step that every business can take with a little focus, effort and determination.  Less paper means less use of trees and less transportation (and petrol), reducing a merchant’s carbon footprint. Not all customers will be happy to turn off paper immediately but some will and they will slowly encourage the others to do the same.

So Paperless billing  is a worthy goal for all merchants
Whether you’re a large merchant billing tens or hundreds of thousands of customers, or a small business raising a handful of invoices, on-line billing at an aggregation site (such as PaySwyft) is a pain free way to trial the paperless option.

Merchants can raise some or all of their bills online...or test dual billing with late payers and measure the impact on cashflow...or if they prefer, give customers a straight choice: paper or paper free.

Paperless Billing: at a glance:

Merchants are saving money on...

·        Printing paper bills

·        Fulfilment, postage and franking

·        Undeliverable mail

·        Chasing late payments

·        Handling manual payments

·        Archiving paper bills

·        Reconciliation/bill matching

Customers are saving time on...

·        Checking and paying bills

·        Hunting for previous bills

·        Checking funds and means to pay

·        Writing and posting cheques

·        Waiting for a merchant to be open for business

·        Talking to customer services

·        Worrying over lost cheques and late delivery

Friday, 30 November 2012

What is the difference between “push” versus “pull” on-line billing?

The terms “push” and “pull” are now commonly mentioned when on-line billing is being described, but what do these terms actually mean in this context and what is the advantages of one over the other? 

A “push” based on-line billing process essentially means that a consumer is prompted or alerted directly with a full invoice, statement or other document describing what has been purchased and what needs to be paid. This is therefore what is commonly called a “rich” document. For the most part, push-based on-line billing systems are carried out as e-mail notifications with attachment files (such as a PDF for example).

A “pull” based on-line billing process will still alert a consumer that an invoice is ready to be paid but instead of including the rich document, invites the consumer to go to a nominated web site where they can find the full bill to be viewed and subsequently be paid in digital form.  Both e-mail and text messaging can be used to simply alert the customer, but merchants may elect to use off-line notifications (letters, paper-based invoices etc) as well.

Both push and pull models on online billing offer merchants the opportunity to reduce or eliminate paper invoices over time but each has advantages and disadvantages.

The advantages and disadvantages or Push-based on-line billing
Push based on-lined billing has the advantage of using a very common and familiar system that most businesses and consumers now use with relative ease -their email. Recipient addresses are unique and go straight into an inbox to be read either immediately or when the person opens their email system. In addition, emails are now readily received on mobile phones and other portable devices, allowing for very fast delivery, flexible viewing and (in some cases) access to online payment options.

Despite the above, there are a number of drawbacks with this push-based delivery model. They include:
* An email address may be incorrect or not reach the right recipient directly
* Many individuals and even organisations may have inbox restrictions the size of incoming emails. This will limit the opportunities for presenting invoices (especially when the attachment is large in size).
* Staff turnover in businesses and changes to email addresses by consumers means that it is often difficult to ensure the complete integrity of email addresses.
* Recipients can claim that they never received an email with an attached e-bill
* It is not always easy to differentiate copy invoices from original invoices with push on-line billing.
* An attachment (such as a PDF) is still only a piece of paper. A consumer may just print it and pay it offline and/or a merchant cannot easily reconcile the data (needing to key in the data again).

The advantages and disadvantages or Pull-based on-line billing
In Pull-based on-line billing, an email is more equivalent to a paper-based notification in the physical mail and simply serves to alert the customer that an invoice is available for viewing and processing at the nominated billing website (the biller’s own or a third-party aggregator’s one). As well as presenting the invoice a fully digital and therefore clickable format, web 2.0 internet technology also makes it possible to distinguish between the original and copy invoice. In addition, this fully digital format makes for very simple upload or transfer to an accounting system, thus eliminating any requirement to key in data manually and greatly aiding the reconciliation process. In addition, full digitisation allows the recipients to view their bill and render payments all on-line, at the same web site (which they may choose to do as soon as it is received).

Just as with Push based on-line billing, there are nonetheless a number of drawbacks with this pull-based delivery model. They include:
* Recipients may forget their logins and passwords to the billing web site to which they are being directed
* Recipients may not trust the web site to which they are being sent, or least feel nervous about the security offered (especially where payments are concerned)
* Consumers may be confused with what is likely to be a simplified bill or one which approximates to the one they receive in the mail-it is often similar but not the same.
* The billing web site may not be very user-friendly (leading to consumer abandonment)

So, in summary, we can say that both push and pull on-line billing have many advantages worth considering but also have a range of disadvantages that need to be considered one-by-one according to each merchant’s needs. In overall terms perhaps there are less onerous disadvantages on the “pull” side, and it is this approach consequently has the present advantage. However, as usual in the online world, choice and convenience are always key considerations, and it may well be that offering both a push and a pull-based solution offers the best outcome of all (and most quickly attains the paperless system than many merchants may crave). 

Sunday, 25 November 2012

What is the real cost of paper-based versus electronic billing

This might seem to be quite a simple question at face value but when we think about it, the answer is not exactly a straightforward one. This is because we are not always aware of the real costs of performing this quite complex task in all of its steps. In addition, while direct or tangible costs are relatively easy to identify, indirect costs are less easily identifiable and some of these are often very well hidden. Let’s therefore look at what tends to fall into these three categories of costs when comparing traditional paper-based billing versus full on-line or digital billing.

Direct Costs
At face value most people would estimate that a few “direct” costs are involved in paper-based billing. These may include:
•Invoice bill/file preparation/printing
•Paper invoices/bills
•Printing (ink or cartridge replacement)
•Envelopes
•Postage/Franking
•Offering basic payment options (debit, credit, other at standard fees)
Costs will fall as bill volumes increase for most of the above but even if they do postage or franking at about £0.40 to £0.45 pence will always be the biggest fee here. And the others will typically add as much as 30 to 35 pence making for a total of £0.70 to £0.80 of direct costs. Of course, if a merchant emails invoices (with a PDF attachment), instead of physically mailing them this may fall in half perhaps.

Indirect Costs
Costs are often deemed to be “indirect” because they are either fixed and/or cannot be wholly charged to the billing costs (especially if it is only part of a person’s job). However, even proportional costs add up here. Indirect costs may include:
•Customer service manpower to handle calls/queries
•Accounting/Reconciliation manpower
•Lost invoices (and the time taken to deal with this)
•Undelivered bills (and the time taken to deal with this)
•The cost of bill storage (space rental or fixed costs)
•Bill query handling time
Once again there may be some economies of scale in the above but all of these items (except bill storage perhaps) mainly involve having staff on the payroll or at call. Even at 500 bills a month, at least quarter a person would typically be involved in issuing and reconciling invoices and another quarter in handling queries, re-issuing bills or handling “special requests” related to invoicing or payments. If the cost of this person (or two part-timers) were £12,000 a year (£8,000 plus 50% salary/overhead burden) or £6,000 each, this £1,000 a month would amount to £2 per bill.

Hidden Costs
Costs are often deemed to be “hidden” because no-one is scrutinising or controlling them (they go unmeasured or unaccounted for or are lost in general overhead or the broad costs of doing business). Hidden costs may include:
•Extra or hidden payment transaction fees (which may be fixed or higher than necessary)
•Invoice/billing run or payment processing errors
•The need for a higher than wanted or necessary float/overdraft at the bank
•Possible added customers or more business from having more payment options
•Quicker settlement/cycle time (by use of SMS or email alerts)
•Easier training of staff/opportunity to focus staff elsewhere with time saved
•Potential cash-flow acceleration
•Easier/cheaper compliance and audit work with digital billing
•Lower/No cost digital marketing opportunities
•Overall incremental "Green" benefits/credits

The benefits to an organisation of the long list above are obviously much harder to calculate but a variety of studies in recent years have suggested that these can conservatively add up to as much as 3-4% of revenues or as much as 15% of profit. If we assume our little company doing 500 bills a month has an average transaction or “ticket” value of £40, turnover per month is £20,000 or £240,000 per annum. If we assume that profit is 15% of this or £36,000, this all means that the cost per bill is somewhere between £0.90 to £1.20.

So in summary, if we add all of these costs together which have a total traditional or paper-based billing cost of £3.60 to £4 or 9.5% of the revenue collected each time (£40 average ticket value). Now that’s a quite a serious amount of money for this little company not to take pretty seriously! But what about your company?-what is 9.5% of your revenues? And when you have calculated it in cold hard cash, can you afford not to investigate the potential to save as much as half of this as recurrent savings every year by moving to digital billing?

Sunday, 29 July 2012

Can Merchants really turn off paper bills with digital billing?

Within the billing world, going paperless has been almost like a “Holy Grail” for many merchants, and especially those who are sending out thousands, hundreds of thousands or even millions of bills a month in some cases. And who can blame them? Merchants who send out more than just a few hundred invoices each month are typically spending a great deal of money on printing, putting invoices into envelopes, sending out reminders and/or statements, franking the envelope, having to engage in making sure bills are filed or stored properly and fielding calls from customers who don’t receive a the bill in the mail at all (so it has to be resent) to name but a few things.

By adopting a paperless invoice or digital bill only solution, a merchant can technically avoid all of the above and “switch off paper” immediately. However, despite the apparent significant  advantages to the merchant, this may not be the best way to go (and it should also not be the driver of the change to digital billing).

Most customers have been getting bills in the mail, or at least ones they can print if they are sent by email, for many years and many want to stick with a process that they well understand. Hence, any merchant that removes the option of receiving a paper bill risks losing a customer’s business altogether. Far better therefore to retain the option to receive a physical bill and either deliver it by cost-effective e-mail or allow a customer to retrieve it and print it for themselves from a central website.

With a cloud-based system such as PaySwyft, not only can any merchant post a digital bill but allow customers to print the bill whenever they like. Even better a merchant can email the bill if they so wish, including follow-up or chase bills. And once customers are using such a fully digital portal they can also use a whole range of convenient technology to manage their bill in more flexible ways. This includes:
  • Receiving a monthly e-mail notification when a new invoice is available to view.
  • Decreasing the possibility of mail fraud and identity theft.
  • Automatically calendarising or secheduling payments at a time or date to suit them
  • Set email and/or SMS alerts as they like
  • Store and retrieve all invoice and payment records whenever they like, forever
  • Make payment 24 hours a day, 365 days a year
  • Pay in a multitude of ways at the same portal and get a receipt there and then
  • See all of their invoices and payments when they want
  • Analyse invoice trends and patterns as they wish

This does not mean that they will necessarily “turn off” the paper bill, or stop printing it, but over time the resistance to doing so will clearly lessen. And in the meantime, not only is the customer getting a convenient service for free, that they can use at work or home on their computer (and save themselves time if they were previously paying by cash or cheque in particular), but a merchant is saving money on many fronts, including fielding less phone calls, accelerating cash-flow with earlier online payments and reconciling payments in a much more straightforward way than ever before. Given all of this, getting to a paperless world, if and when it happens, is only a minor bonus.

Saturday, 14 July 2012

Will Mobile Phones Become the Dominant Channel for Bill Delivery?

There are now a multitude of channels available to customers to pay their bills. These channels include:
1. Print and mail (paper-based)
2. Fax
3. Email with embedded data
4. Data interchange (system-to-system)
5. Email with PDF and/or link to on-line
6. Customer Web Portal
7. Mobile (MMS; HTML; WAP; USSD)
8. Mobile via App
9. Mobile Tablet
10. Emergent technology (via cable TV etc)

Only print and mail on the above list existed as an option until around 30 years ago when fax arrived and 25 years ago when email came along (both of which still have quite a strong following today). Data interchange options were mainly evolved and used in the B2B rather than direct Business to customer or B2C space but again are still around today as a strong channel, supported in the main by large international software companies, who have sufficiently large installed volumes to want to protect their position in the billing market.

Web based technology has driven the greatest change in the billing space in the last 10 years or so and seen the emergence of both consumer and merchant portals (for presentment and payment) and the use of mobile technology as 3G and 4G have made the internet available to mobile phones.

Even though each of these channels presents a new and perhaps better and more convenient choice to a given customer (and are often presented as the channel to replace earlier channel choices) in reality, they are often just additional options. In other words, consumers have shown time and time again that they like the extra choice but do not necessarily want to be driven too quickly to only one channel (however “efficient and effective” it is presented to be).

The implication of customers wanting lots of channel choice to both view and pay their bills is that the same bill may need to be presented and rendered possible to pay in several channels, at least for now.

Today’s challenges
Some technology experts are starting to say that customers will be move rapidly away from e-billing to m-billing (m for mobile of course) in the next few years. Modern mobiles can certainly handle very complex tasks today - just look at the hundred of thousands of Apps available for all different platforms. These Apps can do complex tasks, even generating bills “on-the-fly”. A mobile can also handle a simple task such as bill presentment with ease today – in some cases on quite a detailed basis (even though reading it may present quite a challenge!). However, viewing a PDF bill attachment on a mobile (as opposed to a tablet) is often a long scrolling exercise, making it impractical in most cases. There is a solution to this but it needs the biller to solve the problem of displaying their bills in more flexible ways according to the kind of mobile platform to which it is being delivered. In this way, a customer can see a simple version of the way and then “drill into the detail” as they wish when they want to see itemisation. 

However, perhaps all of this is a false dilemma. In the final analysis, customers do not care if a bill is delivered to their computer, their tablet or their mobile (or even all three). In fact, many want to see it delivered in as many ways as possible to allow maximum flexibility, including by email or by PDF attachment and even in the physical mail or fax on some occasions. This multi-channel approach is therefore a customer centric approach. The challenge for billers then is how to provide as many of these channels as possible at the lowest cost possible. In the end there is only one solution to this –use a full digital bill presentment and payment portal, such as PaySwyft for example. This not only means that a bill can be sent in all nine of the current channels above (and can be paid at the same portal) but means that a biller would be well-placed to take advantage of the new emergent technologies that will come along in the near future.

Wednesday, 19 October 2011

Can a Third-Party Digital Billing Company Put Big Savings on the Bottom Line?

In a recent article, we broadly confirmed that a general claim of the international billing and payment research companies was true for two companies (one small and one large) and that it is therefore likely to apply more widely. This claim is that on average every organisation spends around 5% of its revenue on issuing invoices and collecting payment for them. Now that we believe this claim to broadly accurate, in this article I want to test the claim of some third-party electronic billing and payments companies that they can make cost savings of up to 50% if their clients adopt a fully digital billing and payment service. At the full 50%, this would mean that up to 2.5% of a given company’s revenue would be saved. And as the large company in our previous article had an annual turnover of £90 million, this would amount to a whopping £2.25 million (and that’s certainly worth having as recurrent additional income).

To properly analyse this situation, we first need a few facts. In the information below therefore are some statistics about the company which we called Beta in the earlier article:

What this chart tells us immediately is that Beta spends slightly more than 5% of its revenue on issuing invoices and getting them paid, with 43% of this £4.62 million cost being on the staffing side and 57% being on the transactional cost side. So, now that we know this, where is the particular scope for savings, taking each of these two headings separately?

A) The Staff side savings potential
By moving to a fully digital billing solution, there is an expectation that many more people will be happy to both get/view their bills or invoices on line and pay them by the same means. However, this is not going to be the case for all customers and even for those who do make the transition, it takes time. For our purposes here we will therefore estimate potential take up after a three year period, at which point, 50% of Beta’s customer base is happy to view their bills online and half of these (or 25%) are happy to pay online. For simplicity we could say that this is a switch of 35% of the customer base to online billing and payment (the other 65% staying with previous practices and methods).

The implications of the above is that Beta cannot cut or redeploy its staff too aggressively, as the majority of customers still need to be serviced in the old way. However, we can nevertheless estimate that staff man-hours necessary to tackle the new workload (and therefore numbers needed) are reduced as follows:

Accounting: The 50% of customers now viewing their bills on line and the 25% paying by online means, allow much easier settlement and reconciliation, with electronic records at every step, less errors and much easier analysis of data (because the digital billing system can be used for the entire customer billing process and not just part of it). As a result, the people handling invoicing and payments could be reduced to a manager plus four accountants at Beta (a reduction in staff of 38%).

Clerical staff: Quite high numbers of clerical staff are needed at Beta to handle the 25% cheque and cash mix, general data entry (with records often being keyed two, three and even four times on occasions) banking and the chasing of invoices when overdue. Because there is also likely to be faster payment in the electronically paying customer base, this reduces the amount of time chasing late payments. In summary, data administration is simplified considerably across the whole system. As a result, the people handling invoicing and payments could be reduced to a manager plus fifteen clerks at Beta (a reduction in staff of 39%).

Call-centre staff: 50% of all Beta’s payments are taken on the phone, where service agents have to find the customer data and invoice, take the payment manually and payment data to a system of some kind. With a fully digital solution being used by 50% of the customer population, and half of these paying on line, the burden on the call-centre is reduced by 25% (as there is no need to contact the call-centre anymore for these customers). In addition, call-centre staff may be able to convert more and more customers to online payment by showing them the digital invoicing and payment system and pointing out that this is available 24/7, 365 days of the year-and not just 9am-5pm call centre hours. As a result, the people handling invoicing and payments could be reduced to a manager plus forty agents at Beta (a reduction in staff of 30%).

All of the above adds up to staff savings (even with a lower overhead recovery now of 40% as there are less offices, desks, computers etc needed) of £730,056.

B) The Transactional cost side savings potential
We have assumed no change in Beta’s business in terms of revenues and overall transactional volumes (and therefore average cost of each transaction). There are, however, two major changes that a digital system is likely to bring:
1. A change in bill presentment costs
2. A change in the mix of payment types being used

Bill presentment costs: Now that 50% of the customers are viewing their bills on line, it is reasonable to assume that they are happy to see paper “turned off”. As Beta were emailing invoices previously this was a preparation cost mainly (on the staff side) but it does allow the opportunity to send statements electronically as well as give customers copy invoices in the new digital system forever as a free service. This means that paper and envelope costs would reduce, as well as the need to store physical paper copies within the Beta organisation or externally (so costs of storage space are reduced also). Perhaps more significantly, the marketing material send in the post by Beta can now be put online for half of the customers (where it is presented without the cost of having to send it out). All up, savings in all of these presentment areas for Beta are estimated to be £481,035 per annum.

Payment costs: In the new world, a fully digital presentment and payment solution is likely to half Beta’s volume of cheques and eliminate the use of cash completely (even though the option to pay by cash may still be available to customers in some solutions –such as the one offered by PaySwyft). On line bill payment however goes up to become 15% of the total mix (with the other 10% coming from credit and debit card payments that used to go through the Beta call-centre). This adds a transactional cost of £0.50 per invoice to Beta, or £116,379 per annum, but it is more than offset by savings elsewhere. The greatest of these is in the float costs of the business. Because online payments are known to get to customers quicker and lead to faster payment, cash flow is accelerated and days outstanding are reduced (in Beta’s case from 45 days to 38 days (a drop of 22%). This contributes a total of £123,288 in annual savings to Beta. In addition, the often linked costs of having to handle bounced cheques, chasing debt and writing off unpaid invoices, diminishes considerably, adding another annual saving of £387,931.

If we add all the transactional side potential savings up, the total is £924,908

Summary
So, on the staff side we have estimated total savings of £730,056 and on the transactional cost side estimated total savings of £924,908. This makes a grand total of £1.652 million in savings per annum (recurrently) or 1.84% of revenue. Hence, the claim that a good digital billing system can save a company 50% of its costs (or in this case 2.5% of revenues) is not quite met here. However, with the potential to add more savings over future years as more and more customers switch to the new online system it would get very close to the 50% target and make the switch to digital billing still seem like a very good idea.

To make the above figures easier to see at a glance, a summary of all of the above is presented in the table below: